Truckers, loggers push back on Oregon's climate proposals


SALEM — Dozens of industrial trucks drove laps around the state Capitol Wednesday, blaring their horns and releasing plumes of diesel into the air as part of a demonstration against Oregon's climate policies that loggers and truckers say will devastate their business.

It comes as a key legislative panel approved a cap-and-trade program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, setting up the ambitious climate proposal for a full floor vote. The bill, along with another addressing diesel emissions from heavy-duty trucks, are meant to reduce the emissions behind global warming and stem the tide of climate change.

Some employers have welcomed the changes, saying cap and trade has been carefully negotiated for over a decade and will actually bring new, high paying jobs to some of the most remote parts of Oregon.

“This actually opens the door to an incredible amount of high paying jobs,” said Matt Swanson with the Northwest Carpenters Union, which represents carpenters and construction workers. “As we transition to cleaner technology, we will need more construction workers on the ground, including in rural areas, to build new infrastructure.”

The program sets aside $10 million every two years for investments in transitioning displaced workers to clean energy jobs, providing unemployment benefits plus career and technical training. There are also wage and labor standards built in to ensure these new jobs offer fair pay and other worker benefits.

But truckers and loggers say that there's no reason for the state to move forward with such an ambitious climate platform since Oregon's emissions make up far less than one percent of the global problem. Workers add that such emissions changes would put them out of business, raising fuel and equipment costs.

“It's the height of conceit and arrogance to say that we are responsible for this issue or that we could even do anything to fix it,” said Gregg Budge, who owns his own trucking company in Vernonia, northwest of Portland. “If their concept of climate change is a real thing, Oregon is such a minuscule part of this world that this legislation would do nothing.”

Under a cap-and-trade program, the state puts an overall limit on emissions and auctions off pollution permits or “allowances” for each ton of carbon industries plan to emit. Only the largest polluters are targeted, and the idea is that as the emissions limit becomes stricter over time, it will be in industries’ financial interest to switch to green technology. The state ultimately aims to reduce emissions to 80% below 1990 levels by 2050.

The change is expected to raise gas prices by about 22 cents a gallon for the first year, with gas rising above $3 dollars a gallon by 2050, according to the Legislative Revenue Office. Some of those costs would be returned to low-income drivers under a fuel rebate program written into the bill.

The trucking industry is also likely to experience a reduction in tax rates, which state economists say will lower some of the financial impacts of the program.

But truckers maintain that even with those caveats, the proposals only showcase how little lawmakers understand industry in rural Oregon. Truckers have to buy their own trucks and in many cases aren't reimbursed by employers for the price of fuel.

They say that they're being punished double by lawmakers: cap and trade would raise fuel prices, while a proposed clean diesel bill would require some truckers to buy new engines or vehicles__upgrades that can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars.

The diesel measure aims to phase out diesel engines produced before 2007, and the proposal only applies Multnomah, Washington and Clackamas counties, which are primarily urban areas.

Senate President Peter Courtney addressed a crowd of protesters outside the Capitol, acknowledging their frustrations with the proposals.

“I see you glaring at me and I get that,” he told a crowd, adding that he wouldn't “celebrate” the passage of either proposal.



David S. Wall

If Oregon adopts a Cap and Trade program the economy, as we understand it, will collapse. Already there are a myriad of Legislation in both House and Senate that is destroying agriculture and forestry economies.

Look at the legislation targeting the Eastern Oregon Border Region. There are many Bills which will add carbon to the atmosphere in order for Eastern Oregon Border Region to develop economically to compete with Payette County, Idaho.

There is legislation for the Economic Development and housing for rural areas. This is a guarantee carbon will increase as the agricultural economy will be destroyed.

Corporations are already pressuring Yamhill County Commissioners with permits to erect solar farms on irreplaceable and priceless farmlands.

Oregon derives electricity from burning municipal garbage because Oregon does not have a ZERO WASTE policy. This too must change.

Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) will create a very expensive infrastructure to carry out the mandated functions.

The biggest drawback to this tomfoolery of carbon reduction resides in; the estimates, the credits eligible households will pay as opposed to equivalent treatment of all households, the immense record keeping will be rife with corruption, enforcement will be unequal and very, very costly.

Oregon should be focusing on clean energy development, complete recycling of everything, cleaning water ways and the oceans adjacent to Oregon, rebuilding forests, planting orchards and other plants that will support pollinators like butterflies and honey bees.

There are many more ways to save the planet. Cap and Trade is never going to work, period.

David S. Wall

Don Dix

To follow and produce costly legislation upon a flawed, unproven 'hypothesis' (climate change, global warming), is typical of Oregon's government lately. They seem so frantic to be first, or one of the first, the rush leaves common sense completely out of the discussion.

Cap and trade is just another vehicle to raise taxes. A 65% increase in state tax (22 cents/ gal. 1st year), diesel taxes per gal. will exceed 80 cents. Based on who controls and writes many of Oregon's legislative actions (public unions), those new taxes dollars will never be used to actually reduce anything except the cost of living for all outside the realm of public employment.

Courtney is the epitome of BS -- his track record reveals he has no intent of doing anything to answer the frustrations and real problems of this legislation, or work to fix it -- but he 'acknowledges' them -- now don't you feel better?

Web Design and Web Development by Buildable