By Emily Bonsant • Of the News-Register • 

Lafayette finds funds for fire truck

Only current online subscribers may access this article and/or our N-R e-editions.

One-day subscriptions available for just $3.

For all subscription offers, click here.

Already a subscriber, please

Comments

scooter

1of2
I understand the concern around aging apparatus and the reality that replacement costs have increased dramatically over the last several years. Nobody is arguing that the current engine will last forever.

That said, many of the same questions raised during the original discussion still don’t appear to have been publicly addressed before moving forward with this purchase.

This is reportedly a second out engine in a department that continues to struggle with staffing and response capability. Public discussions focused heavily on volunteer headcount and overnight staffing numbers, but those alone don’t necessarily reflect actual service delivery. The more important questions are things like:

What are the department’s actual response times?
How many personnel are typically responding on apparatus?
How often is this engine actually utilized on incidents?
How often are Lafayette units arriving in a position to impact incidents within the city?

Those are measurable metrics already tracked through dispatch data, and they seem important to evaluate before committing nearly a million dollars in public funds toward a replacement.

There are also still fair financial questions that were never really addressed publicly. During the original meeting, the Chief estimated the current engine could potentially bring around $100,000. Given the age, mileage, idle hours, and obsolete parts concerns discussed, has that number actually been market-checked? Based on comparable apparatus sales, it seems more likely the city would realize a value far below that estimate, potentially under $10,000.

scooter

2of2
At the end of the day, this is a major taxpayer funded capital purchase, and I think many residents were hoping to see a more data driven public discussion around service levels, response capability, utilization, and operational need before the decision moved forward.

The concern was never simply that the engine is old. The concern is whether replacing this particular apparatus meaningfully improves service delivery for the community relative to the other challenges that were publicly discussed.

This was never about being anti volunteer or anti fire department. Lafayette has a beautiful new station that the community is paying for, and it’s reasonable for residents to expect service level discussions and operational data to be part of major capital decisions like this.

Hopefully the council starts asking the kinds of questions that are answered with real operational data and measurable service metrics, not assumptions or generalized talking points.

I still look forward to seeing what the council finds the actual data shows as this process moves forward.

  • Most viewed
  • Most commented
Web Design and Web Development by Buildable